How do certain implements feel to a spankee? (research)

[danielking]

I don't have personal experience from any impliments but in my general creative writing I have some child characters who do, and I'd like to be able to reference them and write possible spanking scenes as realistically as possible without the personal experience.

And take note, only one of these implements (plus maybe the open hand) would be used for any one spanking.

All bare bottom:

- a hard-wood hairbrush's smooth side, otk position
- a light but well chosen bundle of fresh birch twigs, otk position or bent over some furniture
- a heavy leather belt, not the buckle part
- a thick and rigid cane, not rattan
- a rattan rod

So people who have been spanked with any of these in their childhood or adult years, would you share how they felt when used...
- instead of the open hand?
- after being first warmed up with the opem hand?
- how different does the open hand feel if used after one of the implements?
- difference when a strike falls on the sitting spots as opposed to the upper parts of the bottom?
- what differences different techniques from the spanker may make?
- if the feeling significantly changes after the spanking has crossed over to the level of severe?
- how easily do these implements bruise or wound? (My parent characters never want to bruise or wound their children and wish to avoid it as well as possible while using one implement.)

Any personal experience comments will be highly appreciated, even if you can't or choose not to address every single detail asked about! Even if you have experienced these only during your adult years, you can help. If you have childhood experience knowledge, remember to not reference any real child but yourself alone in your own childhood.

Thank you in advance!

[milf]

From personal experience on the receiving end of hairbrush, belt, single switch, and rattan cane out of those listed between ages 7 and 21, not had the bun busting thick cane, or birch rod....

Hairbrushes can and do bruise your buttocks/thighs pretty good unless you're getting very light smacks, or only a few. I never got light spanks, or less than 25 with an hairbrush and I always had at least some small bruises after. Heavy belts will mark you very quickly, and bruise you even faster than any brush since belts cover a lot more territory with each spank. Again this is unless your just playing and not really spanking. After all, if a parent/authority figure is going to spank you as a punishment it is MEANT to HURT! And if they are going to use a implement, its meant to be scary and painful enough that you never want to repeat what got you spanked! Yes it's done in love, and is never really wanted to be done, thus it has to be extremely effective to not be needed often. As for rattan canes... Depending on if it's an Nursery, Junior, Senior, or Reformatory size one.. (each is thicker than the last).... Nursery canes take a lot to bruise most bottoms, a lot of strokes, or extremely hard strokes. You can get 24 to 36 before you really are black and blue Junior canes can leave bruises with each stroke depending on who is using it, though usually you can take 18 to 24 strokes before being too badly bruised. The Senior canes on the other hand, usually have your rear bruised very quickly, and it really hurts to sit after 6 to 12... And 18 can have you nearly crying every time you sit for at least 2 days... 24 or more, and even walking hurts for a couple of days, and sitting on the toilet is misery!

Of course as an young child I hated being spanked in any way until after age 11ish. Then I was fascinated, and by 13 was actively looking to get spankings from everyone that could spank me. By 16 I was seeking out severe spankings so I am definitely not your average chip off the block.

Now for the list: I will do Hairbrush today.. and then later on do the belt, cane etc...
- instead of the open hand? The open palm packs a good sting, and usually the pain is not as bad as the sounds of the spanks, whereas an hairbrush, at least the ones I got on my bare bottom the pain equaled the smacking, then eclipsed it. The pain explodes in an flash of white hot sting, and also an deeper burning into the tissues of your rear. As the spanks add up, the pain truly intensifies both on the surface, and deep in as the hairbrush both gives sting, and thud. And the pain builds extremely fast compared to the hand spanking. Usually I could take dozens of hand slaps before really getting too sore to resist, but only 12 or so with the hairbrush had me in real tear territory. by the time I had received my full spanking with the hairbrush, I was totally limp and crying uncontrollably, and an snotty mess LOL.
- after being first warmed up with the open hand?
Though an warm up with hand made the pain much worse, it did make it take longer to really bruised up. hence if I was in for an severe spanking with the hairbrush, I got a long hard spanking by hand first. Extremely rarely over outer clothing, and rarely over underwear. 90% of my spankings started out bared. Before age 15 I would usually get around 70 to 80 swats by hand, unless I was really in trouble, then it was at least 100. Then I got minimum of 40 to 50, and up to nearly 100 with the hairbrush. After age 16, that jumped up much higher with the hand warm up being much closer to 150 to 200 by hand, then anywhere from 100 to 200 by brush. The single worst time I got spanked by hand until my mom's hand hurt, and I lost count of brush swats after 150. After it was over, My entire backside, from the tops of both buttocks, out to edges of hips, and down to mid thighs was so swollen and bruised that it hurt to even pull up thin underwear for 3 days. That was the time I learned not to smoke weed, lie about it, and then threaten to set my mom up to get arrested. Technically it was abuse yes, but I deserved every swat I got.

- how different does the open hand feel if used after one of the implements?
After your backside is very sore from the hand, and then hairbrush, another dose of hand is much worse, unless you're numb then it's the psychological effect that is tough.
- difference when a strike falls on the sitting spots as opposed to the upper parts of the bottom?
The *Sit Spots* as they are known, is extremely sensitive areas, and every swat there hurts much worse than on the rest of the buttocks, with the exception of that dangerous area at the tops near the small of your back where you can seriously get damaged if the spanker is not careful. The sit spots are the worst though, especially when spanks land inside the inner areas! Ad this is especially true when being spanked in the diaper position!

[naughtypadawan]

Most of my experience is with the hairbrush, but since milf did such a great job with that, I'll skip to the bundle of twigs.

First of all (for what it's worth), "birch" was once a catchall term for any kind of twigs you used to whip someone with. So you could be "birched" with hazel, hickory, willow, or literal birch twigs, among other things. The verb "birch" comes from England, where the local birches are different from the American white birches. American birches have become very endangered since a tree disease started to wipe them out in the 80's, so you'll probably have trouble finding someone to describe what a literal American birching is like.

My sole (adult) experience with birching was with a bundle of ash twigs. These were relatively thick and knobby, and they gave a thuddy impact along most of their length. The stingy part was where the twigs wrapped around my hip. The sting was bearable at first, but then the burn quickly built to something unbearable. I have only used a safeword once in my life, and that was while being birched with ash twigs. Yikes!

[GoodLifeMickey]

Love hairbrushes, slippers and thin canes. Not fond of paddles.

[OwO nya]

Out of the implements you mentioned, I had the most experience with a hairbrush, but I feel like It would be redundant to comment on that since Milf already did such a good job. Hence, I will talk only about belts, but I don't have such a great experience with them. Idk if this is relevant, but my experience comes form the ages of 14-19

- instead of the open hand?
I never actually got a spanking by open hand that would really hurt, It always seemed to hurt the spanker more then me, but my spankers were never really that experienced. Depending on the thickness and weight, it could hurt even less then by hand, more (or just enough) or like a torture device. With the heavy belts, it didn't matter how or where you were hit, it just hurt, you could try to flex your glutes all you wanted, it still hurt like hell. That pretty much summarizes the whole experience.

- after being first warmed up with the open hand?
I'd say it hurts about the same, it is more about the perception of the pain. Since there is more blood flowing through the skin, the pain feels a little more pleasurable, but it still hurts significantly. With hard swings, there is no such thing as erotic spanking with a belt. I would note though, belts tend to be a lot less cumulative then hairbrushes and similar implements, as milf said, hairbrush can hurt a lot more if you hit fast enough so you cannot recover from it, with belts it doesn't matter how often you hit, it just hurts.

- how different does the open hand feel if used after one of the implements?
Actually, really pleasurable and almost erotic. It is more painful then without a warmup, but your body can deal with the pain much better.

- difference when a strike falls on the sitting spots as opposed to the upper parts of the bottom?
I didn't notice a difference, it felt all the same. Although I usually welcomed when it hit on "fresh skin" that wasn't bruised yet.

- what differences different techniques from the spanker may make?
It makes A LOT of difference. If you are in a position where the spanker can't hit you properly or can't swing it well, it hurts a lot less. Once you build up speed though, it is all about the precision. More precise you are, the more it hurts I would say, since you can hit the same part over and over, and in general you are in better control.
I never spanked anyone with a belt (a lot), but from trying it on pillows I would say it is not that hard to get good with it if you have enough space.

- if the feeling significantly changes after the spanking has crossed over to the level of severe?
I was never spanked severely I would say, but when it felt close to it I almost felt numb. Not physically, it still hurt a lot, you just sort of accept that this is what it feels like and imagine how it will be once it is over.



- how easily do these implements bruise or wound? (My parent characters never want to bruise or wound their children and wish to avoid it as well as possible while using one implement.)
Heavy belts bruise really easily, the medium one I was most often spanked by usually "only" left my behind nice and red, but it was over in less then a day.

PS: If you want to hear about wooden spoons though... I could talk about those all day ^w^